| Alice Lloyd College |
| Aquinas College |
| Arizona Christian University |
| Asbury University* |
| Ave Maria University |
| Baker University |
| Bellevue University |
| Benedictine – Mesa |
| Bethany College KS |
| Bethel College – KS |
| Bethel University IN |
| Bethel University TN |
| Blue Mountain College |
| Bluefield University |
| Brescia University |
| Brewton-Parker |
| Briar Cliff University |
| Bryan College |
| Bushnell University |
| Campbellsville University |
| Central Baptist |
| Central Christian College |
| Central Methodist Uni |
| Clarke University |
| Cleary University |
| College of Coastal GA |
| College of Idaho |
| Columbia College(MO) |
| Columbia International SC |
| Concordia University (MI) |
| Concordia University (NE) |
| Corban University |
| Cornerstone University |
| Crowley’s Ridge College |
| CSU-Maritime Academy |
| Culver Stockton |
| Cumberland University |
| Cumberlands,University of The |
| Dakota Wesleyan |
| Dalton State |
| Dickinson State University |
| Doane University |
| Dordt University |
| Embry Riddle – AZ |
| Evangel University |
| Faulkner University |
| Freed-Hardeman |
| Friends University |
| Georgetown College |
| Governors State University |
| Grace College |
| Graceland University |
| Grand View University |
| Haskell Indian Nat U |
| Hastings College |
| Holy Cross (IN) |
| Hope International |
| Houston – Victoria |
| Huntington University |
| Indiana South bend |
| Indiana Tech |
| Indiana University – East |
| Indiana University-Northwest |
| Indiana Univ – Kokomo |
| Indiana Wesleyan University |
| Iowa Wesleyan University |
| Jamestown, University of |
| Judson University |
| Kansas Wesleyan University |
| Keiser University |
| Lawrence Tech |
| Lewis-Clark St. (ID) |
| Lincoln College – IL |
| Lindsey Wilson College |
| Louisiana College |
| Lourdes University |
| Loyola – New Orleans |
| Lyon College |
| Madonna University |
| Marian University IN |
| Marymount California |
| Menlo College |
| Michigan – Dearborn |
| Midland University |
| Midway University |
| Milligan University |
| Missouri Baptist University |
| Missouri Valley College |
| Mobile, University of |
| Montana Tech |
| Montreat College |
| Morningside University |
| Mount Marty University |
| Mount Mercy University |
| Mt. Vernon Nazarene |
| Multnomah University |
| Northwestern College IA |
| Northwestern Ohio |
| Oakland City University |
| Ohio Christian University |
| OK Panhandle State U |
| Oklahoma City University |
| Oklahoma Wesleyan University |
| Olivet Nazarene University |
| Oregon Tech |
| Ottawa University (KS) |
| Ottawa University AZ |
| Our Lady of the Lake |
| Park University |
| Park University- Gilbert |
| Pikeville, Univ of |
| Point University |
| Providence – Great Falls |
| Providence Christian |
| Reinhardt University |
| Rio Grande, University of |
| Rochester College |
| Rocky Mountain College |
| Roosevelt University |
| San Diego Christian |
| SCAD Atlanta |
| SCAD Savannah |
| Science & Arts of OK |
| Shawnee State University |
| Siena Heights University |
| Sierra Nevada University |
| Southeastern University |
| Southwest, University of (NM) |
| Southwestern Christian |
| Southwestern College |
| Spring Arbor University |
| St. Ambrose University |
| St. Andrews University |
| St. Francis, University of IL |
| St. Francis, University of IN |
| St. Mary of the Woods |
| St. Thomas University – FL |
| Sterling College |
| Tabor College |
| Taylor University |
| Tennessee Southern |
| Tennessee Wesleyan |
| Texas A&M-San Antonio |
| Texas Wesleyan University |
| The Master’s University |
| Thomas More University |
| Trinity Christian |
| Truett-McConnell |
| University of British Columbia |
| USC Beaufort |
| Valley City State |
| Vanguard University |
| Viterbo University |
| Waldorf University |
| Walla Walla University |
| Wayland Baptist University |
| Webber International |
| West Virginia Tech |
| Westmont (Calif.) |
| William Carey |
| William Jessup University |
| William Penn University |
| William Woods University |
| Williams Baptist |
| York College (NE) |
|
| * Asbury University is in a three-year transition from an NAIA school to a Division 3 school as of March 2021. |